From cookies to quiche, bakery choices at HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa are available for pickup alongside pies and banana bread.
Order onlineBacon Quiche
$10.00
Egg custard and bacon baked in an all-butter pie crust.
“I first had their delicious Poi Banana Bread at the Surfjack Hotel. The barista at the Surfjack said it was the best on the island and she was right!!! I drove from Hawaii Kai to this cute little bakery on the North Shore. I ordered the Poi Banana Bread and the Bacon Quiche so good. The owner was super friendly and welcoming. Love supporting women and local businesses.”
Vegetable Quiche
$10.00
Egg custard with cheese and vegetables baked in an all-butter crust.
“Clean, fast and friendly service along with incredibly delicious food! Everyone was happy! Had the Perfect plate, Quiche and toasted bread mmmmm. Please excuse the half eaten picture, it smelled too good, lol!!”
9" Pineapple Cream Pie (Eleanor)
$48.00
A nine-inch pie filled with pineapple cream serves as a shareable dessert.
“Wow, this place is amazing! The pineapple cream pie is a must have.”
Peanut Butter Pie (slice)
$9.00+
Peanut butter pie is offered by the slice or as a nine-inch pie.
“Such a cute spot! The food was so good too! We got the chicken pot pie combo that comes with a side salad and banana bread. It was one of the best slices of banana bread I’ve ever had! We added a side of maple butter and it was delicious. The chicken salad sandwich was tasty. We ended with the peanut butter pie and it was sooo good. I want to go back to try the cheesecake.”
Poi Banana Bread (slice)
$4.50+
Moist, sticky poi banana bread; choose mini loaf, slice, or sundae.
“Hier ist eine natürliche und positive Google-Maps-Bewertung auf Englisch: A great little roadside food stand that’s definitely worth a stop! We had the Cold Manic Monkey and a slice of banana bread – both were absolutely delicious. Everything tasted fresh, and the banana bread was incredibly moist and flavorful. If you’re passing by, this place is well worth the detour. Highly recommended!”
Poi Banana Bread Loaf
$24.00
Poi adds a moist, sticky texture to this banana bread loaf.
“Best Strawberry Matcha Lattes ever! Super creamy and addicting! The best poi banana bread on the island. Oh and the carrot cake yessss”
Bag of Choc. Chip Cookies
$13.00
Six chocolate chip cookies are packed together in a bag.
“The baker form Baraboo is the best on the island!! Chocolate chip cookies are amazing!!”
Cheesecake (slice)
$9.50+
Creamy cheesecake offered by the slice or as a nine-inch cake.
“I dream about the pot pies at Hi Pie! They are exactly what I need when I am craving some comfort food. They also have rotating pastries and baked goods which are all SO good!”
At HI Pie Bakery + Cafe, bakery offerings include chicken pot pie with carrots, potatoes, celery and onions in herb-garlic cream sauce, alongside pineapple cream pie and peanut butter pie by the slice.
Bacon Quiche has egg custard, cheeses and veggies in an all-butter crust. Poi Banana Bread Loaf gets its moist, sticky texture from poi. Cheesecake (slice) also comes in a 9-inch size.
Visit us in Haleiwa for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Bag of Choc. Chip Cookies contains six pieces. Whole 9” Quiche comes with a meat or vegetable filling and requires 24 hours' notice.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
