Explore the desserts menu at HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa, HI, and enjoy your favorites with convenient pickup.
Order online9" Pineapple Cream Pie (Eleanor)
$48.00
A full 9-inch pineapple cream pie with a creamy filling.
“Had a coconut pie and a pineapple pie called the Eleanor I think. Both were fantastic and I'm sad I don't live closer. The counter girl was friendly and helpful, and these pies were some of the best I've ever had.”
Poi Banana Bread Loaf
$24.00
A moist, sticky banana bread loaf made with poi.
“A definite must-stop if you’re in town or live on the North Shore. Everything they make is delicious but the poi banana bread is our absolute fave!”
Peanut Butter Pie (slice)
$9.00+
Creamy peanut butter pie served as an individual slice.
“Absolutely adorable shop and kind staff working when I stopped in to try a chicken pot pie, which was amazing. I couldn't turn down a slice of the peanut butter pie either. It did not disappoint. Yum!!!”
HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa, HI offers a delightful desserts menu filled with pies, cheesecakes, cookies, and island-inspired baked goods worth savoring.
Standout choices include Poi Banana Bread Loaf, Pineapple Cream Pie "Eleanor" (slice), Peanut Butter Pie (slice), Cheesecake (slice), and the Chocolate Chip Cookie, each a satisfying treat.
Visit HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa, HI to enjoy desserts your way — dine-in, pickup, or delivery brings the Poi Banana Bread (slice) and more right to you.
Cheesecake (slice)
$9.50+
Creamy cheesecake dessert offered by the slice or as a 9-inch size.
“Best pies on Oahu! The Dessert pies are to die for, I had an absolutely amazing pineapple cream pie and never tasted anything like it before. If you’re looking for something more savory, they have these amazing baby chicken pot pies that are filled with delicious creamy goodness inside a perfectly flaky crust”
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.50
This classic cookie is baked with chocolate chips throughout.
“Wonderful coffee and treats. Super nice staff. Loved the Flower Power decaf tea and oat milk lattes, quiche, sautéed veggie croissant, and banana nut bread. The BEST chocolate chip cookies in the universe.”
Pineapple Cream Pie "Eleanor" (slice)
$9.00+
Creamy pineapple pie served as a slice in a pastry crust.
“The Eleanor Pineapple Cream Pie... oh my goodness, the way I scarfed down this slice must be studied. I devoured this so fast that I am still dreaming about how delicious it was. The cream wasn't too thick or rich. It was light and fluffy. Fresh pieces of pineapple in the cream too. The CRUST though! Wow, perfectly nutty and crumbling. Soooooo tasty. I highly recommend!”
Poi Banana Bread (slice)
$5.00+
Moist banana bread made with poi and served as a slice.
“The poi banana bread is to die for. I read a review about it so stopped here. Got one piece to eat here and then got another mini loaf to go. So good and such friendly staff!”
9' Cheesecake
$75.00
A full cheesecake requiring 48 hours' advance ordering.
“THE BEST PIE IVE EVER HAD!!! It’s not even close. Amazing staff. Casey is so nice and welcoming. Love this place”
9' Peanut Butter Pie
$48.00
A full 9-inch pie featuring peanut butter in a sweet filling.
“Such a cute spot! The food was so good too! We got the chicken pot pie combo that comes with a side salad and banana bread. It was one of the best slices of banana bread I’ve ever had! We added a side of maple butter and it was delicious. The chicken salad sandwich was tasty. We ended with the peanut butter pie and it was sooo good. I want to go back to try the cheesecake.”
Bag of Choc. Chip Cookies
$13.00
A six-piece bag of cookies filled with chocolate chips.
“The baker form Baraboo is the best on the island!! Chocolate chip cookies are amazing!!”
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
