Sweet breads, pies, and cookies make desserts at HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa, HI a tempting addition to your dine-in order.
Order online9" Pineapple Cream Pie (Eleanor)
$48.00
Nine-inch pineapple cream pie with creamy filling and pastry crust.
“The Pineapple Cream Pie is absolutely divine! So light and fluffy! The crust is wonderful. This is a must try!! The owner is very sweet and friendly too!”
Pineapple Cream Pie "Eleanor" (slice)
$9.00+
Pineapple cream pie served by the slice, with a creamy filling.
“The Eleanor Pineapple Cream Pie... oh my goodness, the way I scarfed down this slice must be studied. I devoured this so fast that I am still dreaming about how delicious it was. The cream wasn't too thick or rich. It was light and fluffy. Fresh pieces of pineapple in the cream too. The CRUST though! Wow, perfectly nutty and crumbling. Soooooo tasty. I highly recommend!”
Poi Banana Bread (slice)
$4.50+
A slice of banana bread made with poi, a taro preparation.
“Hier ist eine natürliche und positive Google-Maps-Bewertung auf Englisch: A great little roadside food stand that’s definitely worth a stop! We had the Cold Manic Monkey and a slice of banana bread – both were absolutely delicious. Everything tasted fresh, and the banana bread was incredibly moist and flavorful. If you’re passing by, this place is well worth the detour. Highly recommended!”
Poi Banana Bread Loaf
$24.00
A moist, sticky banana loaf made with poi, a taro preparation.
“The poi banana bread is to die for. I read a review about it so stopped here. Got one piece to eat here and then got another mini loaf to go. So good and such friendly staff!”
Cheesecake (slice)
$9.50+
A slice of classic cheesecake with a smooth, sweet cheese filling.
“Cute place but don't let that fool you. These pastries, deserts and the coffee. Oooooohh. So Good.! Made with love by the owner and it shows.”
9' Cheesecake
$75.00
A whole nine-inch cheesecake available by advance order.
“Best pies on Oahu! The Dessert pies are to die for, I had an absolutely amazing pineapple cream pie and never tasted anything like it before. If you’re looking for something more savory, they have these amazing baby chicken pot pies that are filled with delicious creamy goodness inside a perfectly flaky crust”
Bag of Choc. Chip Cookies
$13.00
Six chocolate chip cookies packed together in a bag.
“The baker form Baraboo is the best on the island!! Chocolate chip cookies are amazing!!”
Chocolate Chip Cookie
$2.50
A sweet cookie baked with chocolate chips throughout.
“Super cute cafe with amazing homemade baked goods. Pineapple pie (light and fluffy 💞), chocolate chip cookies 🍪(killer!), homemade chicken pot pies, coffee, and so much more. Everything is delicious and definitely made with love. 💝”
At HI Pie Bakery + Cafe, desserts range from Poi Banana Bread Toasted With Maple Butter to peanut butter pie by the slice and chocolate chip cookies. Peanut butter pie also comes in a 9-inch size.
Poi Banana Bread Loaf gets its moist, sticky texture from poi. Bag of Choc. Chip Cookies contains six pieces. Pineapple Cream Pie "Eleanor" (slice) is also available in a 9-inch size for your dessert order.
Visit HI Pie Bakery + Cafe in Haleiwa, HI for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Order 9' Cheesecake 48 hours in advance. Poi Banana Bread (slice) is also available as a mini loaf or sundae.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
